Dec 03, 2010 the volume that the future and eventually former miriam panofsky carries is one of many signs that the director, richard j. Richlers book came out in 1997, but as stated in the article snopes have traced the legend back to at least 1987. Barneys story is told in retrospect, in the form of a response to a book written by a cop who is convinced barney murdered his best friend. Robert lantos adapts barneys version for screen the new. Gursky was here 1989, and barneys version 1997 satirize the condition and. Life was absurd, and nobody ever truly understood anybody else.
I began to read barneys version on an overseas flight, just prior to its publication, some. Barneys version by michael konyves based on the novel by mordecai richler. Barneys version is a movie that spends a good chunk of its running time getting everything just right, and then fumbles through an ending that does everything absolutely wrong. Barney s version of events may be viewed as that of two unreliable narrators, in that his recollections are told from varying mental states and then posthumously edited by his son. Barney books are a series of books that focus on barney and related characters. In this essay, i will focus on the relationship between empathy and readers choice of ending. Barneys version movie trailer official hd synopsis. With barneys version richlers outsider has become an insider not. Barney s version by michael konyves based on the novel by mordecai richler.
Gursky was here 1989, and barneys version 1997 satirize the condition and hypocrisy of modern society through black humour. What disturbs me most about mordecai richlers 1997 novel, barneys version, now available in a new paperback edition as well as a major motion picture with paul giamatti, is that it took me almost 15 years to get around to reading it. The picaresque and touching story of the politically incorrect, fully lived life of the impulsive, irascible and fearlessly blunt barney panofsky. Near the end of the novel, michael explains barneys philosophy. In order to do this i have chosen two narrative texts mordecai richlers barneys version 1997 and dennis lehanes shutter island 2003, both of which have open. Barneys version is a lifeaffirming and lifespanning drama with the type of difficult, abrasive yet compelling curmudgeon lead that only giamatti was born to play and give the required justice. Jan 27, 2011 the bigbudget film adaptation of richler s final novel, barney s version, has brought with it an avalanche of new vintage paperbacks, with paul giamatti smirking wryly from the peak of a stacked. It has everything you could want from a novelhumor and poignancy, complexity and passion, eloquence and. Shakespeare, tolstoy, or even dickens, understood more about. I liked this book when i first read it years ago ill admit, i was mesmerized by it this time around.
Barneys version is a narrative, where the protagonist gives a summary of his life and what he has achieved so far. But by the end of what he calls this story of my w. Barney panofsky is the type of man that takes a nononsense approach to life and relishes in the absurdity that it often brings. Barneys version by mordecai richler, michael panofsky, bernard cohen. The film was nominated for the golden lion at the 67th venice international film festival. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Barneys version is a bold and emotional triumph of tone, character, structure, and plot a film that, like life itself, mixes the sweet with the sour and doesnt provide much in the way of escapism. Based on mordecai richlers prizewinning comic novelhis last and, arguably, bestbarneys version is the warm, wise, and witty story of barney panofsky paul giamatti, a seemingly ordinary man who lives an extraordinary life. It is barneys side of the murder and his life, and it leads up to and devolves from that fateful evening when, far from being angry, he felt joy in a bedroom scene that would be his ticket to live with miriam. Before his brain began to shrink, barney panofsky clung to two cherished beliefs. Some are more educational in tone, while others are simply stories read for entertainment. Barneys version vintage international kindle edition by richler, mordecai, michael panofsky. Barneys version is based on a 1997 novel by mordecai richler, whose the apprenticeship of duddy kravitz 1959 is also the life story of a flawed but lovable jewish character from montreal.
Readers may never love barney panofsky, the selfdestructive, selfloathing, derisive, womanizing, hottempered antihero of richler s latest novel. The story is written as if it is an autobiography by barney panofsky recounting his life in varying detail. Forget the apprenticeship of duddy kravitz this is the novel that richler should be best known for. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading barneys version vintage international. Barneys version by mordecai richler the canadian book. May 11, 2019 opening and closing to barneys night before christmas 1999 vhs duration. Lewis, based on the novel of the same name by mordecai richler. Barney s version vintage international kindle edition by richler, mordecai, michael panofsky. He is wealthy and basically has everything he has ever. With paul giamatti, rosamund pike, jake hoffman, macha grenon. Based on mordecai richler s award winning novel his last and, arguably, best barney s version is the warm, wise and witty story of the politically incorrect life of barney panofsky. Apr 24, 2015 barneys storybook treasury stars the beloved purple dinosaur and includes three of barneys favorite stories for young readers.
Since the end of his second marriage, barney has lived under the. Dont let hollywoods sugary adaptation put you off reading mordecai richlers acid novel, barneys version. Barneys night before christmas credits 1999 youtube. Huggo spanning more than three decades, barneys version is the eponymous, acidic, and selfcentred canadian television producer barney panofskys firstperson confessional of a lessthanordinary life. Mordecai richler s 1997 novel barney s version which barney s version is based on plays with the idea of the unreliable narrator. Sep 23, 2009 i liked this book when i first read it years ago ill admit, i was mesmerized by it this time around. The picture is downright schizophrenicand thats a shame, because in those early passages, it appears to be doing something genuinely unique and daring, forging a tone that is odd but engaging, quiet yet epic, and. I read mordecais barneys version and i saw the movie. There is his first wife, clara, a flamehaired, flagrantly unfaithful free sprit. Lewis, and the writer, michael konyves, of barneys version. In his novel barneys version 1997, mordecai richler. Shakespeare, tolstoy, or even dickens, understood more about the human condition than ever occurred to any of you. His most recent book is on snooker july 28th, 2001.
Barney s version is a 2010 canadian comedydrama film directed by richard j. Taking place in montreal, barney is a hard drinking, hard smoking, foul mouthed, confused writer and producer, who is given up life struggles with numerous obstacles as the story goes on and nothing seems to be going his way. The volume that the future and eventually former miriam panofsky carries is one of many signs that the director, richard j. I must note that it is not difficult to notice the similarity between mordecai s barney s version and bellow s masterpiece herzog, both in terms of the protagonist and in terms of the writing style. Barneys version by michael konyves based on the novel by. Barney panofsky is a hard living, curmudgeonly television producer, and barneys version is the story of his lifes successes and failures, professional and personal. Barneys version is an autobiographical account written in old age, and annotated with footnotes by his priggish and obsessive son.
Nov 28, 2010 after trying for 10 years, robert lantos has finally succeeded in making a film of barneys version, his friend mordecai richlers last novel. The making of mordecai richler movie barneys version. Barneys version, the longgestated screen adaptation of mordecai richlers 1997 novel, succeeds at reproducing its authors tone as well as prior richler cinematizations. He often tackles the difficult roles, and this is a fine example. Barney panofsky paul giamatti begins his adult life by taking a soulless but successful job in television and marrying his pregnant, nogood girlfriend. He is the recipient of dozens of literary awards, among them two. After trying for 10 years, robert lantos has finally succeeded in making a film of barneys version, his friend mordecai richlers last novel. The bigbudget film adaptation of richlers final novel, barneys version, has brought with it an avalanche of new vintage paperbacks, with paul giamatti smirking wryly from the peak of a stacked. Jan 14, 2011 based on mordecai richler s award winning novel his last and, arguably, best barney s version is the warm, wise and witty story of the politically incorrect life of barney panofsky. Dec 23, 2010 the making of mordecai richler movie barneys version. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Charged with comic energy and a steely disregard for any pieties whatsoever, barneys version is a major richler novel, the most personal and feeling book of a long and distinguished career. Mordecai richler is the author of ten successful novelsincluding barneys version 1997, solomon gursky was here 1989, cocksure 1968 and the apprenticeship of duddy kravitz 1959as well as numerous screenplays, essays, childrens books and several works of nonfiction. Barney s version is a narrative, where the protagonist gives a summary of his life and what he has achieved so far. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading barney s version vintage international. Readers may never love barney panofsky, the selfdestructive, selfloathing, derisive, womanizing, hottempered antihero of richlers latest novel.
Barney panofsky giamatti is living with his best friend boogie speedman in rome. Actually, the urban legend is based on this bit from richlers book. I suspect that is because i am edging closer to barneys age and ive drunk my share of single malts, etc. You could almost call this book a murdermystery as the event of barneys friends death is constantly up for discussion in the book. Barneys version by mordecai richler the pluviophile writer. Based on mordecai richlers award winning novel his last and, arguably, best barneys version is the warm, wise and witty story of the politically incorrect life of barney panofsky. Barney s version by mordecai richler, michael panofsky, bernard cohen. Barneys version vintage international kindle edition by. Opening and closing to barneys night before christmas 1999 vhs duration. Robert lantos adapts barneys version for screen the. Barneys version quotes showing of 32 i dont hold with shamans, witch doctors, or psychiatrists. Apr 01, 2010 barneys version movie trailer official hd synopsis.
I must note that it is not difficult to notice the similarity between mordecais barneys version and bellows masterpiece herzog, both in terms of the protagonist and in terms of the writing style. I read barneys version the novel because i loved the movie. Underlying the story of barney s three marriages is the mysterious disappearance of his friend boogie. The individual effect of barneys three closest buddies boogie, leo and cedric on his marriages is also shown. This onepage guide includes a plot summary and brief analysis of barneys version by mordecai richler. Mordecai richler booklist mordecai richler message board. Barney tells his story after the onset of alzheimer s disease, and then his notes are reedited by his son, so it s hard to know what s 100% accurate. Huggo spanning more than three decades, barneys version is the eponymous, acidic, and selfcentred canadian television producer barney panofskys. Barneys version vintage international kindle edition. A very unreliable character who is responsible for the narration of the book, leaving readers unsure on whether to trust him not.
Barneys version, by mordecai richler kevinfromcanada. The making of mordecai richler movie barneys version the. From the opening lines of the story, richler gives us a gruff, complicated yet sympathetic barney panofsky. In the final chapter with one sentence mike panofsky describes his father with pinpoint accuracy. Barneys storybook treasury stars the beloved purple dinosaur and includes three of barneys favorite stories for young readers. I read mordecai s barney s version and i saw the movie. I read barney s version the novel because i loved the movie. If you have read richler and enjoyed him, barneys version is a book not to be missed. Before his brain began to shrink, barney panofsky clung to two ch. The ending also offers a jawdropping conclusion, which i wont spoil. Both are excellent even though i enjoyed the book more than its cinematic version. Diego hernandezromero vhs openings and closing 1,054 views. Told in the first person, it gives us the life and what a life. Barney panofsky the main character in the book who is the most dramatic and entertaining.
1000 1516 1048 1032 1197 1647 942 1033 774 178 72 421 729 1348 557 210 615 1432 1583 695 1599 579 1041 798 425 1423 1132 576 907 176 469 1301 1517 692 785 1614 1004 1127 618 772 88 117 1442 1341 449 1487 607 36 56 1387